Are There Historical Mistakes in the Quran? (Answering Islam Part 7)

Posted By on October 10, 2019


During the time of Muhammad, lots of stories
were circulating in Arabia. Some of these stories were true, and some
were false. Historians can often separate true stories
from false stories by examining the evidence. They use the historical method. They ask, “What are our earliest sources
for this story? Do we have multiple sources or just one? How reliable are these sources?” Things like that. But Muhammad didn’t know anything about
historical investigation, and so he just couldn’t tell the difference between true stories and
false stories. Let me give you a few examples to show you
what I mean. In Surah 18, Allah tells us that Alexander
the Great traveled so far West, he found the place where the sun sets. Not only can I guarantee you that Alexander
the Great never found the place where the sun sets, we know that this story was a popular
story during Muhammad’s lifetime. The story was even circulating in a Syriac
work titled “The Glorious Deeds of Alexander” towards the end of Muhammad’s life. Earlier in Surah 18, we read about the “Companions
of the Cave”—a group of people who supposedly went to sleep in a cave and woke up three
hundred years later. This myth goes back to Bishop Stephen of Ephesus
around the middle of the fifth century. According to Surah 19, Jesus began preaching
as soon as he came out of Mary’s womb. This story comes from the sixth-century Arabic
Infancy Gospel. The story of a bird teaching Cain how to bury
his brother in Surah 5 comes from Mishnah Sanhedrin. The legend of Mary giving birth under a palm
tree in Surah 19 comes from an apocryphal work called the History of the Nativity of
Mary and the Savior’s Infancy, written in the early 600s. The account of Jesus giving life to clay birds
in Surah 5 comes from a second-century work called the Infancy Gospel of Thomas. It seems that Muhammad simply took the stories
that were popular during his lifetime, gave them an Islamic twist, and included them in
the Qur’an. What’s interesting is that even the pagans
of Mecca were better at recognizing fiction than Muhammad was. Surah 6, verse 25 of the Qur’an says: When they come to you to argue with you, the
unbelievers say: These are nothing but fables of the men of old. So according to the Qur’an itself, pagans
were telling Muhammad that the stories in the Qur’an were known fables. They were myths. They were fairy tales. From a Christian perspective, the most important
historical error in the Qur’an is the claim that Jesus wasn’t killed and wasn’t crucified. In Surah 4, verses 157 to 158 we read: They [“they” here are the Jews] said (in
boast), “We killed Christ Jesus the son of Mary, the Messenger of Allah”—but they
killed him not, nor crucified him, but so it was made to appear to them, and those who
differ therein are full of doubts, with no (certain) knowledge, but only conjecture to
follow, for of a surety they killed him not. Nay, Allah raised him up unto Himself; and
Allah is Exalted in Power, Wise. Now there are multiple historical problems
with this passage. According to the Qur’an, Jews were boasting
that they had killed “the Christ.” “Christ” means “Messiah.” I’ve never heard a Jew boast about killing
the Messiah. The only people who would boast about killing
Jesus were people who regarded him as a false Messiah. The verse also says that Jews were boasting
about killing “the Messenger of Allah.” Here again, the only people who would boast
about killing Jesus were people who regarded him as a false prophet, not people who regarded
him as a messenger of God. Then we have the claim that Jesus wasn’t
killed and wasn’t crucified. This is an amazingly inaccurate claim, because
historians and New Testament scholars agree that Jesus’ death by crucifixion is one
of the best-established facts of ancient history. And I don’t just mean Christian scholars. Even atheist and agnostic historians are certain
that Jesus died by crucifixion. Atheist New Testament scholar Gerd Lüdemann
declares that “Jesus’ death as a consequence of crucifixion is indisputable.” John Dominic Crossan, of the infamous Jesus
Seminar, says that there is not the “slightest doubt about the fact of Jesus’ crucifixion
under Pontius Pilate.” There are lots of Muslims nowadays who like
to quote Bart Ehrman, because he criticizes the New Testament. But Ehrman writes: “One of the most certain
facts of history is that Jesus was crucified on orders of the Roman prefect of Judea, Pontius
Pilate.” These scholars aren’t simply saying that
Jesus may have died or that he probably died. They’re saying that Jesus’ death by crucifixion
is indisputable, that there’s not the slightest doubt about the crucifixion, that it’s one
of the most certain facts of history. And again, these aren’t even Christian scholars. So the Qur’an clearly contains historical
errors, not only because it denies Jesus’ death by crucifixion, but also because it
contains numerous fables, even stories that were recognized as fables by the pagans of
Muhammad’s time. This makes it very difficult to accept what
the Qur’an says about history.

Posted by Lewis Heart

This article has 100 comments

  1. ITS VERY FUNNY HOW PEOPLE SUCH AS DAVID WOOD A FORMER DEVIL WORSHIPER CAN BECOME THE ALL KNOWING CHRISTIAN AFTER READING A FEW BOOKS LOL…ITS SO FUNNY HOW YOU CAN FIND SOMETHING THAT YOU LOVE AND CAN ONLY LOVE IT BY EXPELLING HATRED TOWARDS ANOTHER RELIGION AND USE LIES TO DO IT LOL…I OBSERVED IN THIS 8 PART SERIES HOW DAVID WOULD SAYS TYPICAL 1 + 1= 2 COMMON SENSE KNOWLEDGE BLENDED IN WITH LIES AND MYTHS TO ATTAIN AN OVERALL SENSE OF TRUTH…FOR THE LAME THIS TECHNIQUE COULD WORK TO THE KNOWLEDGEABLE NEVER…THE SADDEST AND SICKEST THING ABOUT NEANDER VALLEY HUMANOIDS IS THE THEIR LOVE OF HATRED AND CORRUPTION/CONFUSION…I HOPE YOU FIND YOUR WAY WOOD…PART 5 WAS ACTUALLY THE MOST ACCURATE DEPICTION YOU HAVE EVER GIVEN ON THE TOPIC OF ISLAM…KUDOS TO YOU!!!

    Reply
  2. Christians peace
    Its OK to change ur religion
    Love your enemies
    Don't use Jesus's name in any crime like killing
    One woman and respect them
    MUSLIMS
    Kill them because they are not believers
    4 women. One man honestly I wanted to change to islam because of this cos u can't do that in Christianity

    Reply
  3. "Get Rekt" to Islam
    -David Wood 2K17

    On a side note, how we know that Islam is false and created by Satan is the fact that God only Allows Satan to do things. Satan can't do something that God does not allow. Which means that Satan cannot be accurate when it comes to prophecy, history, or science because God would not allow Satan to use actual facts to decieve the masses.But he does allow Satan to decieve. This is how we know Islam is false and made by Satan:

    1. Muhammad is the most inaccurate prophet in history

    2. The Qur'an has over 100 Scientific mistakes

    3. And the Qur'an has over 100 Historical mistakes.

    Satan can never be right in anything that he does. He just counterfeits anything that God does because Satan can't create. And if Satan can't create and only counterfeits God then that means he will be wrong prophetically, scientifically, and historically 100% of the time and that's exactly what the Qur'an is.

    This is how we know that the Bible is the Word of God:

    1. The Genesis account of creating uses the exact same methods, in order, that Scientists use to figure out how things came to be.

    2. The bible mentions over 15 times in the Old Testament of an expanding universe which didn't even become scientifically proven until the 20th century

    3. There are dozens of verses that describe the earth as a sphere

    4. There are dozens of verses that describe the earth to be floating above nothing

    5. If you use stelerium, you can see that the Star of Bethlehem did actually happen 2,000 years ago 2 years before the believed date that Jesus was born.

    6. Jesus, John, Peter, Paul, Moses, Daniel, Isaiah, ect. Are the most accurate prophets in history becoming 100% correct in every single prophetic vision/teaching that they share. Including the rebirth of Israel (that took place in 1947-48) which was first prophesied in the book of Genesis.

    7. The bible is the most accurate book in history when it talks about historic events. For example:
    the discovery of Noahs Ark which matched the exact description given in the book of Genesis. And when they tested the age of the wood it dated all the way back to the time of the flood recorded in the book of Genesis proving that the flood did actually take place.

    8. Recent discoveries prove without a shadow of a doubt that the Exodus did actually take place.

    9. The discovery of the Dead Sea Scrolls proved that the Bible has never been changed because when matched up to the KJV bible it was 99.9% accurate to the Dead Sea Scrolls.

    I could go on and on because there are tons of things that prove that the Bible is the Word of God and that God does exist and that Jesus was the Son of God and our Lord and Savior. For example, he fulfilled over 300 messianic prophesies (everything that he did is historically proven showing that he actually did do these things). Mind you that 109 of those prophecies could only be fulfilled by one man in the entire history of the human race. And the chances for only 20 of these prophecies to be fulfilled by one man is well over 1 in 100,000,000. And he preached from the Old Testament. He wasn't Christian lol. He preached from the onlt Testament and it says that when he was with his Disciples in the Wilderness, he showed them everything from the Old Testament concerning himself. And when a prophecy that Jesus fulfilled was documented, the author of that book would also make reference to the prophecy from the old testament while quoting the prophecy as well.

    These all facts proving that Jesus was who he claimed to be. And there's one indisputable fact about there being a God that's the fact that the Universe has a beginning. The universe is expanding proving that it has a beginning which means that there has to be a beginner. An initial cause. Some will say that there's an endless line of Universes that have been giving birth to other universes. But that doesn't make any sense. Because the only way that could be the case is if every previous universe expanded. So even if that was true, what was the intial cause of the first one? It can't be matter because matter can't create itself. Anything with a beginning requires a cause but anything without a beginning does not require a cause. And sense the Universe has a beginning, and it's scientifically impossible for the universe to come from nothing, it requires a cause. But since God does NOT have a beginning, he does NOT require a cause. Therefore it's more logical to believe in a God than in the big bang theory. For the longest time I thought that the discovery of the complexity of DNA was enough to disprove evolution and the big bang theory and prove the existence of God but I guess atheists don't think so lol. Science favors a God and history favors Christianity. Satan hates Jesus becuase Satan lost his kingdom when Jesus died on the cross for us. Satan took a huge blow when Jesus rose from the dead. So let me ask this one simple question:

    Jesus has been proven to be the most influential historical figure in history. So putting Christianity aside, why don't schools teach the historical life of Jesus in history classes? There's only one answer. Satan did this over time. The U.S was the very first country founded under Christ with our laws created from the teachings of the bible. The nations with the most freedom are Christian founded nations. But now it's a nation that has completly turned it's back on God and said "we don't need you anymore". This is evidence of Satan and the prophesies that Jesus spoke of. He said that all nations will turn on Him and will hate all who follow and accept him in the end times. Well, Christians are now the most persecuted people in the world which is evidence of the accuracy of bible prophecy. Persecution has expanded wider and wider at a quicker pace since 1947-48. He also said that there will be scoffers and people who say "where is the promise of his coming?" I actually didn't know that this prophecy existed until I came across it when I was doing my bible studies. When I saw that, I was in complete awe. Because the one thing that I've seen the most of is exactly that. So many people saying that its been 2,000 years so he's not coming back. All of this is enough evidence for Christianity. Plus, a God that has a beginning is not worth worshiping. And I would never bow down to Allah because of much hate he has towards Jews amd Christians. (which btw is more evidence that it's a religion created by Satan)

    Reply
  4. Today I'm Christian but this was after spending a long time poking around for holes in Christianity. Why did I finally take the plunge? Many reasons really, but one very telling one was the Virgin Birth story – why it was ever insisted that Jesus was born of a virgin! The bible story is that Adam the first man sinned and consequently the whole earth was plunged into corruption. Then God planned a redemption by sending a Saviour in Jesus who would as Adam be originally sinless only then to die for the the sins of others. To accomplish this we are told God brought Jesus into the world without the involvement of a MAN!! The virgin birth! Amazing, isn't it, the audacity of such a claim if it was to no purpose whatsoever! First thing I found out from a casual read of the DNA story is that the blood DNA of every child comes from the child's father. Modern science teaches this only in our lifetime! Mein Gott, but It's practically impossible then that 2nd Century writers of the bible knew this!! How could they have known too that the DNA for blood doesn't come from a mother but the father? God – not wanting Christ to be stained with the sin blood of an earthly father – brought our Saviour into the world and the womb of Mary without natural copulation!!

    For me that really sealed it! The bible had to be true. Such scientific understanding could only have come from the Creator Himself!!!

    Reply
  5. I and Father are One ( john 10.30 )
    The living entities in this conditioned world are my eternal fragmental parts ( lord krishna gita 15.7 )

    And they tempted God in their heart ( psalms 78.18 )
    Iam in everyone's heart as a supersoul ( lord krishna 7.21 )

    The words i say to u are not my own, rather it is the father living in me, who is doing his work ( john 14.10 )
    Iam seated in everyone's heart, from me comes knowledge remembrance and forgetfullness ( lord krishna gita 15.15 )
    Iam the way, truth, and life.no one comes to the father except through me ( john 14.6 )
    Just try to learn the truth from spiritual master.Inquire from him submissively and render service unto him.The self realized soul can impart knowledge unto u because thay have seen the truth ( lord krishna gita 4.34 )

    God said" Let us make man in our image, in our likeness ( Genesis 1.26 )
    Fools deride me when i descend in human form.They do not know my transcedental nature as the supreme lord of all that be ( lord krishna gita 9.11 )

    And there shall be no night there; and they need no candle,neither light of the sun,for the lord god giveth them light; and they shall reign for ever and ever ( revelation 22.5 )
    " That supreme abode of mine not illumined by sun and moon, nor by fire or electricity.Those who reach it never return to this material world ( lord krishna gita )

    Iam alpha omega , the beginning and the end,the first and last( revelation 22.13 )
    Of all creations iam beginning and end and also middle ( lord krishna 10.32 )Of letter iam the letter A and among the compound words iam the dual compound ( lord krishna gita 10.33 )

    Reply
  6. Hello David Wood
    Do you know the Riddle of the Sphinx ?
    It goes like this: What's the creature that when the rises it crawls on 4 and when the sun is Up it walks on Two and when the sun sets it walks on 3 limbs)
    Do you know what the creature is ? if not, the legend says the Sphinx will kill you by putting you under his right pawn.
    The answer is simply: Man (walks with a Stick when he is old – hence the 3 limbs)
    So the Question Proposed by the Sphinx tells us Many things.
    1 – We are all looked upon by the Sphinx as equal Suns.
    2 – The Sphinx is Aligned with the Sun and made even before any pyramid had existed in the Area. (Meaning Man came before creating his womb – the Pyramid) Only in this case they have created 3 Major ones
    3 – The Sphinx is aligned with the equinox Sun rises.
    4 – At the Equinox The Pyramid Khufu can be seen 8 sided only from the air.

    Once you realize that the Answer to the Riddle of the Sphinx is only 1 answer : which is equal to all of us: which is just a human being, You will notice that his Question was composed of 3 Phases.
    Khufu means the Old one in Arabic
    Now to me, after the Riddle had been Solved you might ask yourself , then what about those big 3 Pyramids behind you (The Sphinx)
    He will not answer you. Because you have to find out by yourself, To which one does your religion align to ?

    You are answering all about Islam and comparing it to Christianity, Just because you are standing at the Middle Pyramid, Khefren.
    Which appears to be the Tallest but it is not – also appears to be the biggest of them all , but it is not. It is also the one in the Middle in Straight alignment with the Sphinx and the Sun's Equinox.

    Now , How and Why Does Khufu represent Islam ?
    1 – Well – Because it is the most perfect one.
    2 – Because it is the 3rd or last one
    3 – Because it is the One Closest To North.
    4 – Because from it, looking back at the Sphinx – That would be South Est direction
    which would be representing A Muslim Human Standing on top of the Pyramid of Choice (Khufu) and looking back at the Transmuted / Transfigured Sphinx / The one that is Equated to the Sun (IE Jesus) – which you also are looking at but from a different pyramid.
    This South Est direction from Khufu is the Direction to the Golden ratio point of the Earth >> Which is the Kaaba.

    You will not see the light of Islam as long as you keep Judging it by or trying to align it with what you have been presented.
    Or what you chose, actually > The second Pyramid, which represent Venus By the way. and Khufu represents Earth and the Moon ++ Much more.

    Now The Question is: can the second pyramid be a wonder of the world if there was no Khufu ?
    You are not looking at why it is a Wonder of the World > that's why you keep missing all the points by trying to keep yourself deliberately to the Sun's Alignment and the Second and Sphinx, even though it is not the biggest wonder of the complex
    Even though all what we really want to show you and tell you is that this has been for ages and it is a huge Clock.

    Reply
  7. King David giving chain mail armour wasn't when it was invented in 300bc hope u tell Muslims this and watch one for Israel 2 Israelis who know paleo Hebrew that says messiah is God and God came as a man and angel of YHWH, Jesus real name yahshua YHWH righteousness

    Reply
  8. Buzzing David im banned again because Muslims said there not real Jews but I said Isaiah 11:11 have returned so maybe European Jews might not be true Israelites but real Israelites have returned, I think its Muslims are in doubt over Jesus being crucified because Isaiah Jeremiah Zachariah and David say messiah was crucified, so mighty prophet of God was told God would be the holy of holys that was crucified and if all major prophets God told them messiah was crucified then why do they lie? Muslims like to put Orthodox rabbis that say Isaiah 53 isn't about messiah but about Israel but the babylonian talmud its about messiah and it can never be about Israel because it doesn't fit, rabbis and Muslims say Isaiah 9, 6 is not saying messiah is a mighty God because Jesus said its written were all gods from talmud but Isaiah 10:1 mighty God EL GABBOR is same word in ancient Hebrew for God, and rabbis like to use new Hebrew but Isaiah in ancient Hebrew the messiah would be born from a righteous virgin the same word to describe Rebecca righteous and untouched, Muslims know there loosing so are looking what Jewish rabbis say so they see but rabbis lie talmud says Jesus was a rabbis pupil but the rabbi lived 1st century bc and talmud wrote 500yrs after Jesus, so if Muslims say messiah isn't God then they have to call all major prophets wrong and God a liar simple God doesn't give his prophet false prophesy only those against Ahab and Jezebel and Jews who was going to bow to other god's

    Reply
  9. You don't even speak Arabic and you debate against Islam ! the translations you're reading was written by people who hate Islam just like you, I'm not Muslim btw but I'll be one day

    Reply
  10. David Wood, it's easy to tell something to your flock and have them believe you but please make the effort to debate another knowledgeable Muslim about this. Here are some of your claims that I can refute:

    Alexander the great: nowhere in the Quran does it mention that Dhul-Qarnayn was Alexander. This is the guess of some scholars. Other scholars say it was Cyrus. It couldn't have been Alexander because he was known to be an idol worshipper of the Greek pantheon.

    Jesus preaching as a baby: The Quran actually provides a logical reason as to why Mary wasn't stoned upon coming to her people with a baby. The law of Moses requires the fornicator and adulteress to be stoned or lashed. Mary comes to her people with Jesus. What possible reason could there be as to why her people didn't punish her? The infant Jesus speaking would solve this issue. The Question for you is, if the Quran is false about this then how did Mary free herself from the accusation of her people?

    Jesus not killed nor crucified: Come on, Dave, you can do better than this. You yourself have been involved in debates about this with Muslims and they have refuted you with your own book! The Quran even says "But it was made to appear to them", a phrase which some scholars mean that another person was put in his place and the Jews believed they killed Jesus. In fact, the Christians of old aren't going to be punished for believing Jesus died because prophets can and have died. What they will be punished for is believing he was the son of God, a claim which Jesus never made.

    Reply
  11. I wonder what "evidence" are you talking about (regarding Jesus). Because there is none, Jesus is not mentioned up until some hundred of years after 0 and then just as metaphor/an idea, not a real person. Jesus did not became a real person who was crucified for the sins of manking until again a few hundred years later. The whole Marry-Jesus thing is just like any other religion a stuff of pure faith, there is not one real evidence.

    Reply
  12. So, Islam is LIE founded upon errors in science and history, along with fairytales from various ancient traditions. Is anyone surprised by this? Muhammad was one of the most successful charlatans in history. He was also one of the most stupid.

    Reply
  13. Forget what the quran says. can anyone prove jesus (PBUH) is God and All should worship Him? muslims believe jesus (PBUH) was a messenger not God. We Follow Him, respect Him bt we do not worship him. those who believe jesus (PBUH) is not God rather messenger of God, are Muslim. they are in right way.

    Reply
  14. A Non Muslim who is answering Islam starts his video with a blunder that Quran mentions Alexander doing this and that. Quran never mentioned Alexander. This guy is a doctor, tomorrow he will be questioning medical and surgical procedures and might start a new channel "Answering Medical science". These type of lame and retarded people spread false stories to earn money and fools pay heed to their call. You want to learn Islam? Quran is the best source of it.

    Reply
  15. Wow , no wonder Islamic debaters don't show up to debates Its  only a matter of time before islam comes crashing down totally and crumbles all together as a Christian its easy to see this

    Reply
  16. This point is foolish David. If Jesus died on the cross then God forsook him and punished poor Jesus in the place of evil guilty people .Which just, loving and forgiving God would do such an evil act, think people think!!!! Ounce you start lying about Islam you seem not able to control yourself and keep going further and further. May God deal with you justly and swiftly, as a sign to all the people. Ameen.

    Reply
  17. firstly Alexander the great was not Zulqulnain, the Quran says about Zulqulnain who was not Alexander, and by sun setting it doean t mean it was setting, you see that even newspapwr now a days says thay the sun will set at 8 or will rise at 1, it s just a figure of speech,
    the Quran says that they, the Jews says that we have killed Jesus the son of Mary, not Christ,

    you are saying that Jesus Crucification was a historical fact, it s rubbish because there s not even a single evidence that a man with a name Jesus or Yeshaua ever even existed, people believe that it was a myth and there s not even a single fact that Jesus even existed, so how can they say that he was crucified
    we believe in Jesus because we are told to do so otherwise there s not a single fact about such a person being existed

    Reply
  18. Are you belived in God or just KKK … Islam only asked you to worship one God not three? Are you in true religion if you only hate Islam but ok to other religion? You hate when a Christian convert to Islam…. but when they convert to Budha, Hindu you said nothing , feel nothing… Are you worhip God or what? Anyway… Quran is still free from error…. This video is only to stop Christian people to see the truth not to the muslim…

    Reply
  19. according to muslims, … all these authors and bible scholars mentioned @ 4:39 are MEN, and the Quran is the word of god (allah), there is no contest, who are they going to believe?, the word of man or the word of god. Besides: the Quran is error free!, and how do we know that? because it says so in its 1st page. It's a circular argument, but … we can't tell a muslim that their arguments are circular, we could "offend" them. So how can we win?

    Reply
  20. The fear of death or something close to it is the glue that holds Islam together,take that away and it will eventually collapse.Muhammad knew he had a weak religion he conjured up for more women, more money and more power for Himself. So , He propped it up with death and death it was 32,000 terroir incidents since 9/11.Muhammad in my opinion will go down as the worst human being to ever walk the face of the earth if one counts His legacy.thanks

    Reply
  21. Alexander the great isn't dhul qurnayn because he worshipped pagans but dhul qurnayn worshipped God almighty. Then If u believe Jesus died means simply he's a false and cursed massiah check old testament because he didn't fulfill the sign of jonnah and ur book says that anyone is hanged under a tree or crucified is a curse but Quran defend Jesus that God gave his look to another person some say (Judah or another person) and God lifted him up into heavens so people crucified the person who God gave jesus look . if u believe that Jesus is crucified then he a false/a lair (false massiah) if u believed that Jesus wasn't killed then he is truly the massiah. This is enough evidence that Jesus wasn't crucified nor killed.

    Reply
  22. Well actualy it does say in the quran that jesus was crusifid but allah raised him before he died "naturaly" … you schould learn to read better arabic or get better translation …and sorry for the bad spelling

    Reply
  23. Show your confidence in your religion, science or reason. I suggest you with respect that you follow the Holy Quran, if you don't agree with me? then after death liar will take other's and his whole nation's sins, do you agree? Be brave now.

    Reply
  24. Show your confidence in your religion, science or reason. I suggest you with respect that you follow the Holy Quran, if you don't agree with me? then after death liar will take other's and his whole nation's sins, do you agree? Be brave now.

    Reply
  25. how about man made mistake in the Bible?? check this out. https://youtu.be/U8lRzGHrPC0 Put in and thrown out verses for your own benefit. So this contradict, man made and doubtfull bible is what you guys believe and use to stand against Greatness of Holy Quran?? please check the video. It has two people debate about bible and Quran. Not a mental ill guy called devil wood who was trying to kill his own father (Oh shit that's serious crime) stand up in front of camera alone saying bullshit about Quran with his own interpretation. I Remember he and nabeel made jokes about burning Quran. guess what?? nabeel now burnt in hell. it's one more Satan left. his name is devil wood. people… please stop listening to this clown.

    Reply
  26. So u son of Satan said that muhammad made up Quran from story he took from his era?? How about what Quran said about Jesus that he's son of Mary, miracle birth, messanger of Allah. not son of God, not god. Are that verses he also took from story spread in his era? I better believe in that and not to your church myth and tale_ology of trinity. Hahahahaha. Stupid scam

    Reply
  27. it seems this muhammed guy tend to believe anything that excites him. he'll be like "wait, what if stars are tomahawk missiles of Allah" and he preaches that "revelation.

    Reply
  28. While it is good proof for non muslims but it's not for muslims. because they added "But so it was made to appear to them". They will just say we are a confused bunch who are blinded by allah. even though allah is somehow merciful and just so I don't know why this allah would blind people from truth. but yeah, someone please give me some insights.

    Reply
  29. Hey David, do you take the hadiths and other biographies of Muhammad to be authentic even though they were written well after his death? It seems to me that there are two ways to talk about Islam.

    Reply
  30. We Muslims just want to tell the whole world that the true religion is the religion of Islam, and we do not want our brothers all over the world to get into such a deep valley, it does not mean your religion is not true, just your religion has been mixed by human who do not want the culture of their ancestors to be abandoned, so you all deviate from the doctrine that you should be doing in this world, it is up to you to believe or not to us, we just want you to know. Because when you die that's where it's all revealed, And you can not do anything else. I'm sorry I've been sassy

    Reply
  31. Whatever dude the quraans knowledge exceeded the knowledge of the people of that time and found to be understood by the future generations which is indeed a miracle…but unfortunately debated by the likes of yourselves

    Reply
  32. surprise that david had power to misguide so many people with his stupid comments. bible book of GOD can you prove that first david. every punishment end with kill person. do you think GOD give permission to kill anther person. every body count many death penalties in bible and ask david why GOD says to kill person. people like david misguide people and saying QURAN verse steal from bible. in Quran not give any punishment end with death penalty if quran did copy than why Quran not have death penalty. think people with your brain than follow david. if really want to know about Quran than understand meaning with Arabic word not only read translation. Quran is for all man kind not only for one group. QURAN says in world many people who always misguide people with many others books and that work david kind people are doing. what punishment they will face that is GOD hand but you all trap on his word you people also get punished by GOD. Quran not give to any body to kill anther person for ANY reason. not permissible and so called label Muslim killing anther person they are biblical follower not QURAN follower. QURAN says no difference between any prophets all equal to all man kind for believers. remember david creating hell fire way for people who ever belive him and hate anther person.

    Reply
  33. Dr. Wood, Alexander was from 350BC and even if Mohammed heard some stories of Alexander in his lifetime, surely he wouldn't have believed them to have included those in the Quaran!!!

    Reply
  34. Dr. Wood rather radically overstates how well-established the historical evidence is of Jesus's crucifixion. I think he probably was crucified, but the historical evidence (Christian accounts, of course, don't count) is limited to a single mention by Josephus. Josephus does not state how he come to that information. It is quite possible what Josephus presented as fact was simply a rumor he had heard, started by the Christians. (I don't think that's what happened, but historically it's quite possible.) So a single dubious reference is what Dr. Wood describes as one of the best-established historical events.

    Similarly to most everything else he says in this video. Dr. Wood accepts on faith what mainstream trinitarian Christianity accepts. The books he mentions are Gnostic Gospels. These were ultimately rejected by the mainstream Church, but the church wavered several times before rejecting them under the orders of Constantine. We have no way of knowing if they were right in every instance. We have no way of knowing that the mainstream church is right about these events in the life of Jesus, and that Mohammad was wrong. So in this video David is simply pitting his faith against Mohammad's faith, nothing more.

    Reply
  35. heloo my friends scientific people give me the answers

    First, we deal with Astronomy. The Bible speaks about the creation of the universe. In the beginning, 1st Book, Book of Genesis, 1st Ch., it is mentioned – It says… ‘Almighty God created the Heavens and the Earth, in six days and talks about a evening and a morning, referring to a 24 – hour day. Today scientists tell us, that the universe cannot be created in a 24 hour period of six days. Qur’an too speaks about six ‘ayyams’. The Arabic word singular is ‘yaum’ plural is ‘ayyam’. It can either mean a day of 24 hours, or it is a very long period, an ‘yaum’, an epoch. Scientists say we have no objection in agreeing that the universe – it could have been created in 6 very long periods.

    Point No.2 – Bible says in Genesis Ch. No. 1 Verses No. 3 and 5,…‘Light was created on the first day.’ Genesis, Ch., 1 Verses, 14 to 19… ‘The cause of light – stars and the sun, etc. was created on the fourth day’.  How can the cause of light be created on the 4th day – later than the light which came into existence on the first day? – It is unscientific.

    Point No.3 – Further, the, Bible says Genesis, Ch. 1, Verses 9 to 13… ‘Earth was created on the 3rd day. How can you have a night and day without the earth ?  The day depends upon the rotation of the Earth Without the earth created, how can you have a night and day? 

    Point No..4 – Genesis, Ch. No. 1 Verses 9 to 13 says… ‘Earth was created on the third day.’  Genesis Ch. No. 1 Verses 14 to 19 says…‘The Sun and the Moon were created on the fourth day.’ Today science tells us… ‘Earth is part of the parent body… the sun.’ It cannot come into existence before the sun – It is unscientific.

    Reply
  36. Oh come on. Jesus was meant to be crusified, killed, buried, and on the third day resurrect. I mean that was the primary reason He came. To save us.

    Reply
  37. Mohammed Is a Deceiver
    I feel Bad for him
    Foreal
    I’m not even Joking or being Funny, his soul is In Eternal Fire 🔥 And He has Lead a lot of People To That Destruction And Destination
    But Jesus Christ The Son Of The Father, God in the Flesh is The Lord And Redeemer Of all Humanity
    He alone Can Save us, Muslims Need to Repent And Look To Jesus
    Because he does LOVE THEM and He is The True God

    Reply
  38. David COULD U PLEASE DO A VIDEO REFUTING THE MUSLIM CLAIM THAT SOME ONE WHO LOOKED LIKE JESUS WAS CRUCIFIED AND NOT JESUS HIMSELF?

    Reply
  39. David Wood my beautiful brother, one day when you become Muslim you will be one of the best Muslims. I ask Allah to grant you wisdom to understand the Quran, to find the answers and give you inner peace, All the best for you, we Muslims love you

    Reply
  40. Gen 3:3 But of the fruit of the tree which is in the midst of the garden, God hath said, Ye shall not eat of 3
    it, neither shall ye touch it, lest ye die (your God told Eve. if you eat, YOU'LL DIE).
    Gen 3:6 And when the woman saw that the tree was good for food, and that it was pleasant to the eyes, 6
    and a tree to be desired to make one wise, she took of the fruit thereof, and did eat, and gave also
    unto her husband with her; and he did eat. (Through out your bible, Adam & Eve didn't die EVEN THOUGH YOUR GOD SAID YOU WOULD, SO YOUR GOD LIED AND THE SNAKE WAS TELIING THE TRUTH)

    Reply
  41. WHY NOT ISLAM? YOU PEOPLE HAVE THE EXACT CHARACTERISTICS OF THE JEWS WHO WON'T ACCEPT CHRISTIANITY.
    YOU WANT TO KNOW WHY? ALL BECOZ OF ONE ARROGANCE FEELING SUPERIOR OVER THE OTHER.
    Al-Baqarah verse 6 to 10. AMAZING!!!

    Reply
  42. One thing muslims have to ask themselves, is why did the jews crucify this so called decoy? Is it because the decoy claimed to be the messiah or because Jesus claimed to be the messiah? It doesn't make any sense. The muslim version just makes absolutely no sense.

    Reply
  43. U r the biggest Shetan and the enemy of Islam. Inshallah one day u will accept the Islam and will know the trutness of Quran. Ameen

    Reply
  44. U people are burning from inside bcos u know very well that the quran which is telling us that all are 110% True.

    Reply
  45. if you think that there are some mistakes in the holy quran so you can challenge Zakir nayak a Islamic scholar in india then whole world will see who is right or who is wrong

    Reply
  46. I saw here that some people saying that prophet Mohammed was not a good man and he was not a messenger but we Muslims don't hate Jesus and Moses we believe in all messenger we love them by heart

    Reply
  47. the defferance between you and us is that you don't believe prophet Mohammed as a messenger of God and you not respect him but Muslims believe Jesus as a messenger of God and moses also we believe in all messengers believing in all messengers is a part of our iman

    Reply
  48. We muslims respect jesus you make him a son to god how stupid of a corrupt bible whuch wasnt the torah which came to jesus

    Reply
  49. Muslims believe what they are told by their scholars and imams tell them. They dont read or investigate for themselves. Add to that their blasphemy laws, and you get why Islam has lasted so long😒

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *